July 11, 2009Peggy Noonan Rips Sarah Palin, Again
George Joyce
Why does Peggy Noonan find Sarah Palin so distasteful? Presumably, I am told, it's because Noonan worships at the altar of Ronald Reagan, and Palin is no Reagan. Female friends of mine tell me of a deeper hatred: Noonan is troubled by Palin's family first policy -- that nagging and annoying call from nature which reminds humanity of its proper priorities.
Whatever the case, in today's Wall Street Journal Noonan assembles her arsenal, sharpens her nails, and unleashes her most disturbing and unhealthy attack so far on Sarah Palin. Here are a few tidbits:
"In television interviews she was out of her depth in a shallow pool. She was limited in her ability to explain and defend her positions, and sometimes in knowing them. She couldn't say what she read because she didn't read anything. She was utterly unconcerned by all this and seemed in fact rather proud of it: It was evidence of her authenticity. She experienced criticism as both partisan and cruel because she could see no truth in any of it. She wasn't thoughtful enough to know she wasn't thoughtful enough."
But Queen Peggy is just warming up. To those in the Republican Party who argued that Palin made the party seem more inclusive, Noonan snaps back:
"She makes the party look stupid, a party of the easily manipulated."
Noonan argues, incredibly, that what ultimately destroyed Sarah Palin was Palin's lack of modesty. Palin should have accepted her "inadequacy" -- she should have known her place in other words:
"Her lack of any appropriate modesty did her in. Actually, it's arguable that membership in the self-esteem generation harmed her. For 30 years the self-esteem movement told the young they're perfect in every way. It's yielding something new in history: an entire generation with no proper sense of inadequacy."
Noonan is twisting a very troubling knife here. Instead of recognizing that Palin might have been motivated to help save her beloved country from Obama's socialist revolution, Noonan drifts off into pop sociology.
Think about it. On Iran, Palin would have vocally supported the Iranian demonstrators. On Honduras, she would have defended the Honduran people and their constitution instead of the thugZelaya. She would have talked tough on North Korea. She would have thrown Sonia Sotomayor's application into a dumpster marked "racist." She would have stared down Nancy Pelosi on socialism, unchecked federal power, and the massive debt our children are destined to inherit.
Simply put, Sarah Palin would have done all of this while maintaining her treasured position as a loving mother and wife -- hardly an inadequate achievement.
Now I think I know why Peggy hates Sarah
Kliphnote:
Palin drops out of politics and they still go after her. If you look far and long enough you will find someone that agrees with your point of view. Noonan never says anything about Biden.
Remember, Biden IS the VEEP, NOT Palin.
I just don't understand why the Left hates
Palin but thinks Biden is just fine. A heart beat away from the POTUS.
It's bad enough the Left likes Obama's idea of putting the
US in giant budget hole that my Great grand children will have to pay for. (3-4 X what Bush had, that was passed by a Democratic congress) and like his apology tour. And promise to make America weaker.
4 comments:
"I just don't understand why the Left hates Palin but thinks Biden is just fine"
So Noonan is now on the "Left" because she doesn't fall in line?
Palin is not the VP.
EVERYONE on the left seems to hate Palin.
The last four years Noonan has been on Bush's case.
Did you read the whole thing?
She is clueless.
Do you read any articles by journalist that like Palin,Or just the ones that don't like her?
Tell me more about Biden, the VP, a heart beat from the POTUS.
Do you like him?
You talk about clueless. The guy is a joke. The worse VP in my life time.
Remember Biden is the VP not Palin.
Palin is NOT in politics.
Get over it.
Besides what do you care about Palin?
You voted for Obama.
Let me see.....Obama far left,
Palin far right.
Besides when I want to talk politics I do it on a blog or forum, not facebook or myspace where friends and family can see it.
"Do you read any articles by journalist that like Palin,Or just the ones that don't like her?"
Actually, I don't seek out any articles at all on Palin. It just so happens that the WSJ gets delivered to my inbox every day and has been delivered there for almost ten years now. Noonan is a Conservative. And I do read opinions in favor of Palin, such as yours and "American Thinker," though admittedly I only read American Thinker when it is linked to your posts, as I don't value their opinions nor their scholarship.
Noonan on Palin was character assassination, only.
AT is a high ranking Conservative blog.
I value their opinions more than some some left wing blog like the Huffington Post or the Daily Kos.
Everyone has a blog now.
I had one back in 05 about work and auto workers.
http://www.bloglines.com/preview?siteid=1199969
Post a Comment